September, 2007


30
Sep 07

why I was asking for tux images- engraved laser tux

Much more subdued, subtle, and tasteful (i.e., more in keeping with my current profession) than my previous Pile o’Stickers approach to laptop decoration.

Lasering courtesy Adafruit Industries, who are very cool people- highly recommend them if you’d like to do something fairly interesting and unique with your digital toys.


29
Sep 07

why silicon valley is different than the rest of the world

Seen above a urinal yesterday in a bar in Mountain View: ads for firewalls, security consulting, and used Cisco routers. This is not what you see in normal bars in the rest of the world.


25
Sep 07

glowing, gushing followup on my merely positive roomba review

So, I had a positive roomba review a few weeks ago. I humbly submit that that review was wrong. What should have happened was a totally raving, ‘this is the greatest thing since sliced bread’ review.

cat and older roomba

Here is what I know now that I didn’t know then: the old roomba ate things- shoelaces, power cords, rug fringes, etc. This meant that every time you ran the roomba, you had to make the room safe first.

This is no longer the case. The new roomba seems completely unwilling to eat anything. It detects that something is caught and spits it out. I’ve deliberately tried to force it to behave badly, and it refuses.

This might not sound like a big deal if you haven’t had a roomba, but it is actually huge. In the past, running the roomba was sort of a big deal- it was easier than vacuuming, to be sure, but it still took several minutes of scanning the apartment for obstacles and potential problems. Now every single time I leave the apartment I can trivially vacuum. I just hit the button and go, with no worries.

I’m actually now regretting not getting the more advanced model- in the past, the timer (where you can tell the robot to vacuum on specific days at specific times) seemed silly to me, since you’d still have to remember to clean the floor. Now that you don’t, the timer seems like a great idea- but my model won’t support it. Oops.

Overall, not eating things upgrades the new roomba, for me, from ‘pretty nice’ to ‘every apartment should have one.’ Go forth and bring on the robot revolution.

[Not my cat or my roomba, but cute anyway. Picture by Eirik Newth under CC-BY 2.0. Thanks, Eirik!]


24
Sep 07

best common-sense question asked at my law and econ seminar today

“Why can’t I lease an engagement ring and use the savings to buy a much bigger wedding ring?”

– In discussion of a workshop version of this excellent and intriguing paper, on the leasing of antiquities as an alternative to the very broken bans on trade in antiquities, and the resulting black market (which is not only inefficient, but destroys irreplaceable art.)1

  1. second link is to jstor and may not be available to everyone, sorry. It is “The Economics of Antiquities Looting and a Proposed Legal Alternative”, by Lisa Borodkin, in the Columbia Law Review. []

23
Sep 07

coming back in style

Sock Monkeys!

After an abysmal 9 week losing streak (covering two seasons) I’ve not only won a game in my fantasy football league but I appear to be on pace for the highest score of the weekend. Finally. Krissa was beginning to wonder why I subjected myself to this. Of course, she’ll probably still wonder why I subject myself to this, and with good reason. But hey, it was fun to watch unfold today while I worked on other projects.

Of course, Duke and the Dolphins both lost close games that they should have won, but the Hurricanes won a game they shouldn’t have. So I guess I was 2-4 on the weekend.

[Image: sock monkeys (after my team's name, the Fighting Sock Monkeys). Source picture by Mai Le, under CC-BY 2.0.]


20
Sep 07

one last post about the Busybox/GPL case

Mark Radcliffe, of DLA Piper (I interview there on Monday, by coincidence) has a ‘view from a real lawyer’ on the case.

Mark seems to suggest that the answer to my question of ‘why now’ may be that this is a reaction to the Jacobsen case. While a number of open source lawyers believed that Jacobsen was poorly decided, there seemed to be nearly universal consensus that the facts (and the license) were not ideal, and that instead of appealing, a different case should be found in which to raise the issue. SFLC may well have decided that this is that different case- better facts, better license, and with a party actually interested in the litigation. But we’ll see, of course…


20
Sep 07

three more things worth noting about the GPL case

Following up on the last post after some quick discussions with friends:

  • At this point, this is still merely a complaint- nothing has gone to trial, nor will it for some time. In fact, most cases which reach this stage still never go to trial- they settle before getting that far. Still, this case is notable because it is the first case in the US which has gotten even to this fairly preliminary stage.
  • the complaint asks not just for injunction (which has always been the presumed remedy for GPL infringement) but for financial damages. It will be fascinating to see what theory SFLC uses to calculate the damages- perhaps expert testimony on what the code would have been worth had it been licensed under a traditional licensing scheme?
  • the case is about GPL v2, not GPL v3. The legal theories behind both licenses are substantially the same, so a judicial ruling in this case would be significant for v3- just not decisive.

20
Sep 07

a couple notes on the new Busybox GPL lawsuit

Just read the complaint in the GPL violation lawsuit filed today on behalf of Busybox. Couple things jumped out at me:

  • This is exactly what you think it is: a very straightforward “you are distributing binaries without the source, which you are not licensed to do” case. Nothing complicated here; if the license is valid, Busybox wins, if the license is not valid, Busybox does not win. As a result, the complaint is also a very straightforward document- here is what the license says, here are their options, here is what the license says must occur if the distributor of the copyrighted work doesn’t comply.
  • Traditionally FSF and others who have encountered GPL violation issues have taken the slow and patient approach- working with the various parties over a period of time to come to an amicable conclusion. In contrast, this lawsuit is not only very public, but happened incredibly quickly- the complaint says that the Defendants were first notified that they were in violation on August 28th- not even a month ago. It looks like the defendants have not responded at all, which if I had to guess would be the reason the lawsuit was filed. Still, sort of surprising (given how these things have gone in the past) that it has happened so quickly- I would be interested to see if SFLC or Busybox comments on why it worked out this way.
  • You can see a hint of how SFLC will pursue this in the very first paragraph of the ‘Factual Background’- besides the obvious legal arguments about the validity of the license, the paragraph notes that “BusyBox is … used in countless products sold by more than
    100 manufacturers all over the world, including IBM, Nokia, Hewlett-Packard, and Siemens.” If this actually goes to trial, it is almost certain that those in the courtroom will hear it noted repeatedly that many Fortune 500 companies use Busybox under the terms of the GPL, and profit from it. A decision in favor of the GPL will be portrayed as being a decision in favor of commerce and industry, not just a decision in favor of an abstract license. Is this supposed to matter? No. Does it? Often, yes, it does- judges and juries are only human.

13
Sep 07

IBM(tm) penguin image bleg

(bleg, not lazyweb, because I’ve looked high and low and still can’t find what I need for this project.)

I’m looking for a high-res (ideally vector-AI/EPS/SVG) version of the old IBM penguin:

IBM penguin

I promise it will be used for good and not for evil; I just want to print one copy, albeit in a fairly unusual way.

Thanks in advance…
(Yes, I’ve tried tracing this one, which was the best I could find (cropped out of a screenshot of a flash app), and no, it came out unacceptably poorly.)


12
Sep 07

my blog: the Q&A for law firms and other interested parties

Blogging About

the executive summary:

Nutshell: if you’re a law firm considering hiring me, and you stumble across this blog, please don’t get nervous. Instead, talk to me, and/or read the rest of this post. I’m eager to explain why I blog, and why I think it may make me a better lawyer and a good addition to your firm.

[Image by Hugh Macleod of Gaping Void fame; used with permission under the Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 1.0 license. For more on why Hugh licenses his images this way, see here.]

the full story:

Continue reading →


This work by Luis Villa is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 United States.